* Pro Wrestling Illustrated
o PWI Feud of the Year (2008) vs. Chris Jericho
o PWI Match of the Year (1993)[172] vs. Marty Jannetty on Monday Night Raw on May 17
o PWI Match of the Year (1994)[173] vs. Razor Ramon in a Ladder match at WrestleMania X
o PWI Match of the Year (1995)[6] vs. Diesel at WrestleMania XI
o PWI Match of the Year (1996)[6] vs. Bret Hart in an Iron Man match at WrestleMania XII
o PWI Match of the Year (2004)[172] vs. Chris Benoit and Triple H at WrestleMania XX
o PWI Match of the Year (2005)[172] vs. Kurt Angle at WrestleMania 21
o PWI Match of the Year (2006)[172] vs. Vince McMahon in a No Holds Barred match at WrestleMania 22
o PWI Match of the Year (2007)[172] vs. John Cena on Raw on April 23
o PWI Match of the Year (2008)[172] vs. Ric Flair at WrestleMania XXIV
o PWI Match of the Year (2009)[174] vs. The Undertaker at WrestleMania XXV
o PWI Most Popular Wrestler of the Year (1995, 1996)[173]
o PWI ranked him #1 of the top 500 singles wrestlers of the year in the PWI 500 in 1996[175]
o PWI ranked him #10 of the top 500 singles wrestlers of the "PWI Years" in 2003[176]
o PWI ranked him #33 of the Top 100 Tag Teams of the "PWI Years" with Marty Jannetty in 2003[176]
# Slammy Award for Best Slammin' Jammin' Entrance (1996)
# Slammy Award for Best Threads (1996)
# Slammy Award for Squared Circle Shocker (1996) Won for collapsing; Owen Hart accepts the award for making Michaels collapse
# Slammy Award for Master of Mat Mechanics (1996)
# Slammy Award for US West Match of the Year (1996) vs. Razor Ramon in a Ladder match at SummerSlam
# Slammy Award for Leader of the New Generation (1996)
# Slammy Award for Best Finisher (1997)
# Slammy Award for US West Match of the Year (1997) vs. Bret Hart in an Iron Man match at WrestleMania XII
# Slammy Award for Match of the Year (2008) vs. Ric Flair at WrestleMania XXIV
# Slammy Award for Match of the Year (2009) vs. The Undertaker at WrestleMania XXV
* Wrestling Observer Newsletter
o Wrestling Observer Newsletter Hall of Fame (Class of 2003)[177]
o Best Babyface (1996)[178]
o Feud of the Year (2004) vs. Triple H and Chris Benoit[178]
o Feud of the Year (2008) vs. Chris Jericho[178]
o Match of the Year (1994) vs. Razor Ramon in a Ladder match at WrestleMania X[178]
o Match of the Year (2008) vs. Chris Jericho in a Ladder match at No Mercy[178]
o Match of the Year (2009) vs. The Undertaker at WrestleMania XXV[178]
o Most Charismatic (1995, 1996)[178]
o Tag Team of the Year (1989) with Marty Jannetty as The Rockers[178]
o Worst Feud of the Year (2006) with Triple H vs. Shane and Vince McMahon[178]